National Congress President Davi Alcolumbre (União-AP) rejected on Thursday (21) reading the requests to install a Joint Parliamentary Inquiry Commission (CPMI) on Master Bank, despite pressure from government and opposition parliamentarians. The decision keeps blocked an investigation that already has support from 42 senators and 238 federal deputies — numbers above the required constitutional minimum. ✓
Press quotes (1)
"Foi protocolado nesta terça-feira (3) requerimento para a criação de uma comissão parlamentar mista de inquérito (CPMI) no Congresso com objetivo de investigar supostas irregularidades envolvendo o Banco Master. A iniciativa teve apoio de 42 senadores e 238 deputados federais, número de assinaturas superior ao mínimo exigido."
The CPMI would investigate Master Bank frauds, center of Federal Police's Operation Compliance Zero, which according to Agência Brasil may be "the largest fraud against the National Financial System ever recorded in Brazil, causing potential damage of tens of billions of dollars". The scheme is led by Daniel Vorcaro, the bank's owner, arrested since March. ✓
Press quotes (1)
"A Operação Compliance Zero, da Polícia Federal (PF), completa seis meses nesta segunda-feira (18). As seis fases executadas até 14 de maio trouxeram à luz o que pode ser a maior fraude contra o Sistema Financeiro Nacional já registrada no Brasil, causadora de potencial prejuízo de dezenas de bilhões de dólares."
Alcolumbre justified his decision citing the Senate's Internal Regulations, stating that "requests for reading matters must be subject to presidency dispatch" and that "the timing of reading is a discretionary act of the National Congress presidency". During the session, more than ten parliamentarians presented procedural questions demanding automatic installation of the commission. ✓
Press quotes (1)
"Requerimentos de leituras de matérias devem ser objeto de despacho da presidência. Portanto, o momento da leitura é um ato discricionário [uma escolha] da presidência da mesa do Congresso Nacional"
The main request was authored by deputy Carlos Jordy (PL-RJ), who "personally sought support to guarantee signatures", according to Senate Agency. The case gained new dimension after revelations about meetings between senator Flávio Bolsonaro (PL-RJ) and Vorcaro, leading Flávio himself to publicly defend opening the CPMI to "separate the innocent from the criminals". ✓
Press quotes (1)
"Autor do requerimento, o deputado federal Carlos Jordy (PL-RJ) afirmou que buscará apoio para garantir a instalação da CPMI. [...] O senador Magno Malta (PL-ES) apontou que há resistência em torno da criação da CPMI e destacou a mobilização para a coleta de assinaturas — Normalmente as assinaturas são pedidas nos nossos grupos, e isso ocorre de forma automática, mas aqui foi diferente. O deputado Jordy correu um por um em busca dessas assinaturas"
Alcolumbre rejected reading CPMI requests during Thursday's (21) session
At least five requests have been filed to investigate the Master case
Covered by only some sources, or where the accounts diverge.
Covered by only some sources (2)
Previous political agreement exists between Alcolumbre and opposition regarding CPMI
Flávio Bolsonaro requested R$ 134 million financing from Vorcaro for film about Jair Bolsonaro
Conflicting versions (1)
Number of signatures collected for CPMI
-
Which specific regulatory norms would Alcolumbre be violating by blocking the CPMI?
Why it's still unknown: Parliamentarians allege rule violations, but sources don't specify which constitutional or regulatory provisions require automatic installation
-
What are the details of Vorcaro/Master frauds that would justify the investigation?
Why it's still unknown: Sources mention 'tens of billions' in damages but don't detail specific fraud mechanisms or political connections under investigation
-
How do STF precedents (cited by Lindibergh Farias) apply to the current case?
Why it's still unknown: Deputy mentioned decisions by Barroso (2021) and Celso de Mello (2007) forcing CPI readings, but sources don't detail if cases are analogous
-
What is the current status of injunctions at the STF?
Why it's still unknown: Several sources mention STF actions to force CPMI installation, but don't inform timelines or decision prospects